A while ago I mentioned that a crack team of analysts were mapping every pub ever to have appeared in the CAMRA Good Beer Guide.
For those at the back who haven’t kept up, CAMRA was founded in 1971 to fight the keg beer tide, producing a prototype Good Beer Guide the following year on A4 pages, listing 298 pubs where you could find cask-conditioned ale. At this stage CAMRA stood for the somewhat less snappy Campaign for the Revitalisation of Ale. The first published Guide came out in 1974 and has been produced every year since.
For completeness, pubs on the 1972 list have been included in this project, even though the numerical sequence of editions starts with 1974 (which is still the only one I don’t possess). Assuming the plans to produce a 2022 Guide go ahead, the 2023 edition would become the 50th.
Capturing every pub ever included is harder than you might think so the final figures may still be subject to minor tweaking. Early editions were often vague about the precise location of pubs, usually a name and the briefest of description was provided. A pathological resistance to postcodes didn’t help – they were not incorporated until 2004, fully thirty years after their universal adoption.
In the early 1980s CAMRA included some extra pubs to ‘Try Also’ consisting solely of the name of the pub. It could be a challenge trying to find them in those pre-internet days. Not every pub in this category appears to have left an obvious digital footprint. And that’s before we consider the vexed issue of pub name changes.
Local authority boundaries have also changed over the years so, for example, a batch of pubs placed in Berkshire in the 1974 Guide moved to Oxfordshire following enactment of Ted Heath’s local government act. The legislation also created new and largely unloved authorities such as Avon, Cleveland and Humberside that later disappeared.
Some local branches took matters into their own hands and improvised geographically, contributing to some pubs featuring in more than one county (even in the same edition!). Many more have been placed in different locations. One pub, the Royal Oak at Higher Kinnerton was placed first in England then Wales, in its only two appearances. Two in Hay-on-Wye made a similar international transfer.
The Foresters in Billinge makes the Irish border issue look simple. It debuted in Merseyside in 1976, switched to Greater Manchester in 1979, negotiated a move back in 1981, then reappeared again in Greater Manchester in 1992. It’s still trading and the border became significant last year when the lockdown tiers varied between the two counties.
Scotland’s 1995 reorganisation from regional councils to unitary authorities was spurned by the Good Beer Guide, with tourist board areas inexplicably preferred. Wales has also had boundary changes that the Guide has had to reflect, not always with complete consistency.
Notwithstanding these caveats, the provisional headline findings are:
Total pubs to appear in the Good Beer Guide 31,559*; England 27,312; Wales 2,266; Scotland 1,629; Channel Islands 113; Isle of Man 109; Northern Ireland 90; Republic of Ireland 30; Netherlands 10.
Pubs Closed: 8,183 (25.9%). This is likely to be a slight underestimate as the status of some is unclear, particularly in the context of the pandemic.
Pubs that have appeared only once: 5,807 (18.4%)
Most Pubs in a Single Guide: 6,433 in 1982.
Pubs to appear in every printed Guide: 5.
Most Represented Counties: Greater London 2,020; Greater Manchester 1,195; Kent 1,110; West Yorkshire 1,031.
Future posts in this series will refine the numbers and focus on the history of entries in designated counties and regions.
My thanks to Paul, Rob, Ian and Jim for their selfless devotion to spreadsheets.
*This figure will probably fall by up to 100 as we continue to filter pubs that have been placed in more than one county.
Interesting stats Duncan, out of interest, how many guide pubs are you on to date?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good question. I have been to just under 18k, or at least have recorded that many since 1/1/83. Had a few years wasted drinking before then when I didn’t write them down! However, whilst the large majority of those are GBG listed, some weren’t. My next job will be to match up my lists with the Guide’s total aggregate, less closures. Have a pal who has been to twice that many pubs in total though he is not a GBG completist. Have you kept good records Mick?
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m afraid my records are worse than poor, my only real point of reference are the pubs I’ve reviewed on the Pubs Galore site which currently stands at 1342 and only stretch back to 2014 plus some more on Beerintheevening before that, pre millennium its a case of relying on an increasingly dodgy memory.
LikeLiked by 1 person
To be honest there’s a lot of pubs I went to in the 80s, in my 20’s , that I have no idea now, where they where.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Sounds like a life well spent though!
LikeLiked by 3 people
Very much enjoyed reading this. So many things to ask about, but the one fact that jumped out at me is that ten pubs in the Netherlands have been in the GBG. Do you know why they were given special treatment? Would seem to open the door to the GBG including all manner of pubs on the continent, but I assume that has not come to pass!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Duncan will have an official answer, but I suspect a CAMRA Exec member had a holiday round the, er, historic art districts of the Netherlands and noticed a few had London Pride on handpump and thought it might lead to a sort of twinning arrangement with free trips and beer if they put them in the Guide.
Scott Campbell found a Dutch bar which still has a Fullers handpump !
LikeLiked by 2 people
Thanks Mark. The Netherlands featured in the 1983 Guide only and was anomalous at the time. I don’t know why it was included but there were CAMRA Good Beer Guides to Holland & Belgium, then just Belgium written by Tim Webb. Also recall a Czech and a German Guide. The Tim Webb ones are hugely enjoyable even if you never set foot in Belgium. They give a wonderful feel for the country.
LikeLiked by 3 people
Good recall on the early Tim Webb guides. The Netherland inclusions were only pubs with handpumps, of course, and I imagine handpumps elsewhere were (and remain) a real rarity.
I doubt there’s enough material for a CAMRA book but a guide to British beer and pubs abroad would be a winner.
LikeLiked by 1 person
But why drink British beer when abroad. Virtually everywhere has some high quality local beer. Some places that try cask don’t always manage it well. Mind you that’s true here.
LikeLiked by 2 people
The latest What’s Brewing has an obituary for Guy, who I knew slightly (indeed he signed me up for Pint when I went to my first Dutch beer festival), which mentions him as running cask imports to the Netherlands back then. As I first heard of him through through ex Camra NE, I wouldn’t be surprised if the GBG inclusion was related to his business and was an attempt to promote cask abroad. I’ve been banging on at Camra to have a page on their website listing permanent cask outlets outwith the UK for years. Got to get to the brewpub on the Falklands some day….
There are more bars with handpumps on the continent than you would expect, finding Geueze dispensed in such a manner is a very pleasant surprise. Is the Rosbief chain around Paris still punting it’s dodgy homebrew?
LikeLiked by 2 people
Interesting Scott. Was in Paris two years ago and in a couple with cask, one was badged Burton Ale. I have had some very dodgy cask abroad (and at home!) so suppose CAMRA wouldn’t want to endorse something they can’t quality assess. Is it cask on the Falklands? If they include that in the GBG I may need a few days to get the tick.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Looks like it..https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWWdqgmLZUw
I only think CAMRA should list foreign outlets with a disclaimer as to quality. Some of the Scandinavian cask bars have very good quality, I was really taken with Helsinki, thought it was very weird that the bar in the main railway station had two handpumps (but the quality was good). I think there was more Swedish cask than British.
LikeLiked by 1 person
A few interesting beers there. I nominate you as the perfect compiler of this directory no expenses offered sadly).
LikeLike
When I grow up I want to be a “CAMRA Inspector”, and not one of those Cask Marque wallahs with a thermometer either.
Did you ever see the spoof (I hope) Guide to Manchester Pubs from the 80s ?
LikeLiked by 2 people
You are a CAMRA Inspector. The spoof one sounds good- can’t recall it.
LikeLike
Not the whole Guide, sadly;
LikeLiked by 5 people
Brilliant.
LikeLike
Brilliant work. Well done all. Are there still over 100 pubs on the IOM full stop? They all must have been in at some point!
Covid stopped me in my tracks of visiting every pub with an LS postcode, which I’ve been doing since 2008. Only a dozen or so Old school pubs left but around 50 left when you include micros and bars that keep popping up. Wish I’d blogged them from the start, particularly those that have fallen by the wayside!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Cheers. Good work in your big local patch. Of the 109 to feature on Man we think 40 have closed. But there are others that have not been in so not sure of the total. @NorthIrishSea will almost certainly know.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have got a pdf of the full Greater Grotley Guide – a four-page effort !
if anyone wants a copy, please let me know.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Is this still a work in progress? I think lots of people would like to see a list of which local pubs have been in.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was going to do a county by county post but didn’t think there was too much interest. Are there any areas you would like me to post about?
LikeLike
Merseyside, especially Liverpool and St Helens. I’d guess there are a lot that don’t exist or don’t sell real ale anymore once you get away from the centres.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Good shout. Will definitely do something on this. Toxteth, for example, had plenty entries long since demolished or closed.
LikeLike
Great. The area near Anfield and Goodison and the old Saints ground will have changed a lot.
BTW the way I can comment but can’t “like” a comment ( because I don’t have WordPress account). Not sure if that is a general thing or your settigs.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Researching it as I write this! Not sure about the settings thing. Think I’ll split it into two with Liverpool as a single post then the rest of Merseyside, otherwise it gets too long.
LikeLike